An IS auditor is evaluating the reliability of audit evidence obtained during a review of an outsourced payroll provider. Which TWO of the following considerations most directly affect the reliability of that evidence? (Choose two.)
An independent assurance report provides corroboration from a qualified party and increases the reliability of the evidence about the vendor's controls. It reduces reliance on management representations alone. The auditor should still evaluate the report's scope, period, and the service auditor's competence, but the independent attestation materially strengthens the evidence's credibility.
Why this answer
Reliability of evidence is driven primarily by the independence of the source and the auditor's direct involvement in obtaining it. Evidence obtained directly by the auditor and evidence corroborated by an independent assurance report are the strongest here. Verbal representations and storage location do not enhance reliability, and timeliness speaks to relevance more than reliability.
Exam trap
The trap here is conflating relevance attributes such as timeliness with reliability, and treating management representations as if they were independent evidence.