A network engineer is troubleshooting a DMVPN Phase 3 network where spoke-to-spoke communication is not working. The hub is configured with ip nhrp redirect, and spokes are configured with ip nhrp shortcut. The routing protocol is OSPF, and the hub is configured with ip nhrp map multicast dynamic. The engineer notices that when a spoke pings another spoke's LAN IP, the first few pings fail, but subsequent pings succeed. However, the engineer wants to eliminate the initial packet loss. Which of the following is the most likely cause of the initial packet loss?
In DMVPN Phase 3, when a spoke needs to reach another spoke's network, it initially sends packets to the hub. The hub forwards them and sends an NHRP redirect to the source spoke. The source spoke then sends an NHRP resolution request for the destination spoke's NBMA address, waits for a reply, and then builds a direct tunnel. During this process, the first few packets may be dropped or delayed. This is a normal behavior and not a configuration error.
Why this answer
The initial packet loss in DMVPN Phase 3 spoke-to-spoke communication is a normal occurrence. When a spoke first attempts to reach another spoke, it does not have a direct tunnel. It sends packets to the hub, which forwards them and simultaneously sends an NHRP redirect to the source spoke.
The source spoke then initiates NHRP resolution to learn the destination spoke's NBMA address. Until the resolution completes and the direct tunnel is built, packets may be dropped or delayed. This is inherent to the on-demand nature of Phase 3.
The other options suggest configuration errors that would prevent direct tunnels from working at all, but the scenario indicates they eventually work.
Exam trap
The trap here is assuming that initial packet loss indicates a misconfiguration, when it is actually expected behavior in DMVPN Phase 3.