A company is restructuring its security governance due to rapid growth. The CISO reports to the CIO. What is the PRIMARY risk of this reporting structure?
Reporting to the CIO places security within the IT function it must independently oversee, so IT operational priorities such as uptime and delivery speed can override security objectives. Independence from IT is the governance constraint this structure breaches.
Why this answer
When the CISO reports to the CIO, security objectives are subordinate to IT operational goals. The CIO's primary mandate is system availability, performance, and cost efficiency, which can lead to security controls being deprioritized or bypassed to meet IT project deadlines. This structural conflict is the primary risk because it directly undermines the independence required for effective security governance.
Exam trap
In ISACA CISM, the question tests the distinction between a symptom (e.g., budget issues, compliance problems) and the root cause (loss of independent security authority) when the CISO reports to the CIO.
How to eliminate wrong answers
Option A is wrong because compliance difficulties are a potential consequence of poor governance, not the primary risk of the reporting structure itself; compliance can still be managed with proper controls. Option B is wrong because budget insufficiency is a symptom of misaligned priorities, not the inherent risk of the reporting line; the budget could be adequate if the CIO prioritizes security. Option C is wrong because cooperation between IT and security typically increases when security reports to IT, as they share the same leadership; the risk is that security's voice is subordinated, not that cooperation decreases.