A network engineer receives a call that users in VLAN 10 on Switch B cannot ping the default gateway, which is a router on a stick connected to Switch A. The engineer checks the Spanning Tree Protocol state on the interface connecting Switch A to Switch B (GigabitEthernet0/1) and finds it is in a root-inconsistent state. Which command output best explains the cause of the issue?
Root guard is correctly the cause: when a port configured with root guard receives a superior BPDU (i.e., a BPDU that would make the local switch root or change the root bridge), the port is moved to a root-inconsistent state. This blocks all traffic on the port to protect the existing root bridge and prevent a rogue switch from hijacking the spanning tree. The symptom matches exactly—the port is administratively placed in this state, not in err-disable or loop-inconsistent.
Why this answer
Root guard, when enabled on a port, places that port into a root-inconsistent blocking state if it receives a superior BPDU, preventing the switch from becoming the root bridge. This root-inconsistent state stops forwarding traffic, which explains why users in VLAN 10 cannot reach the default gateway. The port remains physically up but is blocked by spanning tree, so normal interface status would not show a down state, making the root-inconsistent state the key indicator.
Exam trap
Candidates often confuse root guard with BPDU guard: BPDU guard err-disables a port upon receiving any BPDU on a PortFast port, while root guard responds to superior BPDUs by placing the port in root-inconsistent state, not err-disable.
Why the other options are wrong
BPDU guard causes an err-disable state, which would show the interface as down or err-disabled, not as root-inconsistent.
Loop guard places a port into loop-inconsistent blocking state when BPDUs stop being received, not when a superior BPDU is received.
A forwarding state would allow traffic; the problem here is that the port is in a blocked state due to root guard, not a misconfigured VLAN.