A database administrator is troubleshooting a query that runs slowly only when executed by a specific application login. The same query runs quickly when executed by the administrator's login. The administrator suspects parameter sniffing. Which action should the administrator take to resolve the issue while minimizing the impact on other queries?
Trap 1: Create a plan guide for the query using sp_create_plan_guide.
A plan guide can force a specific query plan, but it requires determining the optimal plan and may not adapt to changing data distributions. It is more complex to implement and maintain than a query hint. While it can resolve parameter sniffing, it is not the simplest or most flexible solution for a single query. It also does not allow the plan to vary with parameter values.
Trap 2: Disable parameter sniffing at the instance level using trace flag…
Trace flag 4136 disables parameter sniffing for the entire instance. While this would resolve the issue for the specific query, it could negatively impact other queries that benefit from parameter sniffing. Disabling parameter sniffing globally is a heavy-handed approach and not recommended unless all queries on the instance suffer from parameter sniffing problems. A more targeted solution is preferred.
Trap 3: Update statistics on all tables involved in the query.
Updating statistics can improve cardinality estimates and potentially change the query plan, but it does not directly address parameter sniffing. The issue is that the cached plan was optimized for a specific parameter value, not that statistics are outdated. Updating statistics might temporarily help, but the problem could recur. It is not a targeted fix for parameter sniffing.
- A
Create a plan guide for the query using sp_create_plan_guide.
Why it fails: A plan guide can force a specific query plan, but it requires determining the optimal plan and may not adapt to changing data distributions. It is more complex to implement and maintain than a query hint. While it can resolve parameter sniffing, it is not the simplest or most flexible solution for a single query. It also does not allow the plan to vary with parameter values.
- B
Disable parameter sniffing at the instance level using trace flag 4136.
Why it fails: Trace flag 4136 disables parameter sniffing for the entire instance. While this would resolve the issue for the specific query, it could negatively impact other queries that benefit from parameter sniffing. Disabling parameter sniffing globally is a heavy-handed approach and not recommended unless all queries on the instance suffer from parameter sniffing problems. A more targeted solution is preferred.
- C
Update statistics on all tables involved in the query.
Why it fails: Updating statistics can improve cardinality estimates and potentially change the query plan, but it does not directly address parameter sniffing. The issue is that the cached plan was optimized for a specific parameter value, not that statistics are outdated. Updating statistics might temporarily help, but the problem could recur. It is not a targeted fix for parameter sniffing.
- D
Use the OPTION (RECOMPILE) query hint on the specific query.
The OPTION (RECOMPILE) hint forces the query optimizer to generate a new plan for each execution, using the current parameter values. This eliminates the parameter sniffing issue for that query without affecting other queries. It is a targeted solution that addresses the specific problematic query while leaving the rest of the workload unaffected. The trade-off is a slight increase in CPU for compilation.