A company is decommissioning a data center and must destroy 1000 HDDs and 200 SSDs. The policy mandates that all data be destroyed on-site and that the drives be rendered physically unusable. Which combination of methods is most efficient?
A shredder physically destroys both HDDs and SSDs, meeting the requirement for on-site physical destruction efficiently.
Why this answer
Option B is correct because shredding physically destroys both HDDs and SSDs in a single pass, meeting the policy requirement for on-site destruction and rendering drives physically unusable. Degaussing is ineffective for SSDs due to their flash memory, and overwriting is too slow for 1000 drives and also ineffective for SSDs with TRIM or wear-leveling. Shredding is the most efficient method for mixed media at scale.
Exam trap
CompTIA A+ often tests the misconception that degaussing is a universal solution for all drive types, but candidates must remember that SSDs are immune to magnetic fields and require physical destruction or specialized methods like encryption key destruction.
How to eliminate wrong answers
Option A is wrong because degaussing only works on magnetic media like HDDs; SSDs use NAND flash memory and are not affected by magnetic fields, so they would remain intact and data could be recoverable. Option C is wrong because overwriting with a three-pass wipe is extremely time-consuming for 1000 drives and does not guarantee data destruction on SSDs due to over-provisioning, wear-leveling, and TRIM commands that prevent overwriting all cells. Option D is wrong because while degaussing HDDs is effective, using a secure erase for SSDs is not a physical destruction method and does not render the drives physically unusable as mandated; additionally, secure erase can fail on some SSDs or leave data recoverable if not verified.